Menus
Reds
-
The Shop Red
Moulin De Gassac, Languedoc-Roussillon, France 2022
glass 12 | carafe 22 | bottle 42 -
Pinot Noir
Michael Pozzan, Sonoma, California, 2020
glass 15 | carafe 28 | bottle 52 -
Chianti
Tenuta Di Sticciano, D.O.C.G., Tuscany, Italy 2021
glass 16 | carafe 30 | bottle 56 -
Cabernet Sauvignon
Annabella, Napa Valley, California 2019
glass 18 | carafe 34 | bottle 64 -
Malbec
Bodega Abito La Juventud, Mendoza, Argentina 2022
bottle 40 -
Barolo
Andrea Oberto, Piedmont, Italy 2018
bottle 84 -
Brunello Di Montalcino
Azienda Agricola Collelceto Di Ella Palazzesi, Tuscany, Italy 2017
bottle 93
Whites
-
Pinot Grigio
Giuliano Rosati, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Italy 2022
glass 12 | carafe 22 | bottle 42 -
The Shop White
Di Giovanna, Sicily, Italy 2019
glass 12 | carafe 22 | bottle 40 -
Sauvignon Blanc
Sophie Bertin, Loire Valley, France 2022
glass 13 | carafe 24 | bottle 46 -
Chardonnay
Giapoza, Sonoma Coast, California 2021
glass 14 | carafe 26 | bottle 50 -
Gavi Masera
Stefano Massone, Piedmont, Italy 2022
bottle 46 -
Verdicchio Di Metalica
Bisci, Tuscany, Italy 2021
bottle 48 -
Riesling
Richard Böcking, Mosel, Germany 2021
bottle 52
Sparkling
-
Prosecco
CA' Furlan, Veneto, Italy Non Vintage
glass 11 | bottle 40 -
Moscato
D’Asti- La Morandina, Piemonte, Italy 2014 * 375 ml
bottle 24
Rosé
-
Syrah/Carignan
Moulin De Gassac, ‘guilhem’ Languedoc-Roussillon, France 2019
glass 12 | carafe 22 | bottle 42
On Tap
-
Narragansett
pint 6 | pitcher 20
-
Lagunitas IPA
pint 8 | pitcher 26
-
Six Point Crisp
pint 8 | pitcher 26
-
Allagash White
pint 9 | pitcher 29
Can / Bottle
-
Montauk Summer Ale
$7
-
Stella Artois
$8
-
Austin Eastcider
$8
-
Greenport Harbor Black Duck Porter
$9
Slightly Softer
-
Lemonade
$3.50
-
Iced Tea
$3.50
-
The Standards
$3.50
-
Root Beer
$3.50
-
Cream Soda
$3.50
-
Arnie Palmer
$3.50
-
espresso & tea
ask your server
-
Pellegrino
$7
-
Acqua Panna
$7
Shop Specialties
-
All’ Ways Old Fashioned
Rittenhouse Rye 100, demerara syrup, housemade bitter blend
$15
-
Mr. Tangerine Man
Plymouth gin, tangerine puree, arugula, simple syrup, club soda
$15
-
Strawberry Margarita
Milagro Silver, strawberries, triple sec, agave
$15
-
Pining For You
Milagro silver, fresh pineapple, agave, tajin rim
$15
-
Seasonal Moscow Mule
Reyka Vodka, raspberry syrup, lime, ginger beer
$14
-
Negroni
Bulldog gin, carpano antica, campari
$15
-
Rosé Sangria
peach, pineapple, strawberry, citrus
glass 12 | pitcher 50 -
Fool-Aid Punch
brandy, rum, citrus, grape drink
glass 10 | quart 42
Classics
-
Cosmopolitan
Reyka vodka, cranberry, fresh lime
$15
-
Aperol Spritz
Aperol, prosecco, club soda, orange
$15
-
Espresso Martini
Reyka Vodka, espresso, kahlua
$16
-
Paper Plane
Maker's Mark, amaro, lemon, aperol
$15
-
Whiskey Smash
Buffalo Trace, simple syrup, lemon, mint
$15
-
Jello Shots
ask your shop about the flavor of the day!
$4
Whiskey
-
Buffalo Trace
bourbon
$12
-
Maker's Mark
bourbon
$13
-
Bulleit
bourbon
$14
-
Blanton's Single Barrel
bourbon
$18
-
Monkey Shoulder
scotch
$12
-
Laphroaig
10yr. scotch
$14
-
Balvenie
12yr. scotch
$17
-
Jameson
whiskey
$13
-
Old Overholt
rye
$11
-
Rittenhouse
rye
$12
-
Templeton
rye
$14
-
Michter's US 1
rye
$14
-
Suntory Toki
Japanese blend
$14
-
Jack Daniel's
whiskey
$12
-
Dickel Barrel Select
whiskey
$14
Zero Proofers
-
Phony Negroni
Rocks, orange peel
$8
-
Nojito
mint, fresh lime, club soda
$8
-
Strawberry Margarita
Strawberries, lime, agave nectar
$8
-
Tangerine Lemonade
Tangerine, fresh lemon
$7
 vegan |  gluten free |  gluten free option |
All of our ground beef, chicken and pork is sourced from partners that deliver a 'never ever' product. A 'never ever' program guarantees that these animals have 100% traceability and are not treated with any hormones or antibiotics throughout the life of the animal.
Download PDFShareables
share or snack-
Italian Wedding Soup
chicken broth, veggies, acini de pepe pasta, crumbled meatballs
$11
-
Grilled Cheese Balls
with creamy tomato soup
$11
-
Mini Buffalo Balls
Frank's Red Hot, blue cheese
$14
-
White Bean Hummus
rosemary, pistachio, olive oil, focaccia
$11
-
Ball Trio Sampler
classic ball + classic tomato sauce
spicy pork ball + spicy meat sauce
chicken ball + parmesan cream sauce$16
-
TMS Creamy Mac & Cheese
cheddar, parm cream, grana 12
option to add bacon -
Garlic Bread
with tomato sauce 9
option to add mozz -
Crispy Calamari
with spicy-ish tomato sauce
$18
-
Mozzarella Balls
with classic tomato sauce
$13
-
Bruschetta
seasoned ricotta, marinated tomatoes
$15
Salads
add chicken +6, sustainably farmed shrimp +8-
Simple Salad
mixed greens with shaved radish, chives, and red wine vinaigrette
$10
-
Kale Salad
avocado, crisped sweet potato, sunflower seeds, tahini
$14
-
Arugula
wild baby arugula, shaved fennel, grana, mint, lemon vinaigrette
$13
-
TMS Caesar
romaine, crispy capers, garlic croutons
$13
-
Big Italian
pepperoncini, artichokes, green olives, chickpeas, grana, Italian vinaigrette
$13
Large salad available upon request +6
Shareable Sides
for the table$11
-
Roasted Broccoli
chili garlic
-
Brussels Sprouts apples, onions, candied pecans
-
Kale
sauteed with white wine and garlic
-
Cauliflower
roasted then fried, Caesar seasoned
-
Carrots
ricotta, parsley, mint, almonds
-
Seasonal Risotto butternut squash, brown butter, sage
-
Mashed Potatoes
creamy yukon gold tomatoes, chives
-
Roasted Butternut Squash ricotta salata, saba
-
Lentils
sofritto, sherry vinegar
-
Freshly-Milled Polenta
Wild Hive Farms, grana
-
Spaghetti
pick a sauce
-
Rigatoni
pick a sauce
-
Cavatappi
pick a sauce
-
Gluten free pasta
pick a sauce +2
Balls + Sauce
-
-----
-
BALLS
Classic [contains pork]
Spicy Heritage pork
Chicken
House-made veggie
SPECIAL! Mac 'n Cheese Balls
[contains beef & pork]
w/Cheddar Cheese Sauce -
-----
-
Sauce
Tomato sauce
Spicy meat
Parmesan cream
Pesto
Veggie ragu
Spicy-ish arrabbiata -
-----
-
Just the Balls
your choice of balls and sauce
3 for 15 | 4 for 18 -
Make it a bowl
your choice of balls and sauce
over your choice of...
Spaghetti
Rigatoni
Cavatappi
Gluten free pasta +2
Mashed potatoes
Polenta
3 balls for 22 | 4 balls for 25 -
Bucket O' Balls
20 balls with your choice of ball and sauce
$75
Signature Dishes
big flavor-
Spaghetti in Meatballs
3 large classic meatballs with spaghetti basked inside, each in their own sauce
tomato, parmesan cream, pesto$28
-
Rigatoni Spicy Pork
spicy pork balls, broccoli, parm cream, swift kick
$24
-
Cavatappi Chicken Pesto
mini chicken meatballs, broccoli, mozzarella
$24
-
Lasagna
crushed classic balls, ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce
$24
-
Rigatoni Shrimp
sustainably farmed shrimp, tomato cream sauce, cherry tomatoes, calabrian chili
$28
-
Chicken Parm
buttermilk marinated, mozzarella, tomato sauce
served with a side of spaghetti$28
-
Chicken Milanese
crispy chicken breast, topped with a salad of arugula, marinated tomatoes & onions
$25
-
Mediterranean Chicken Breast
pan seared with olives, tomato, capers, shallot and parsley over butternut squash
$25
-
The Kitchen Sink
your choice of balls and sauce with the chef's selection of seasonal sides and a simple salad
$24
Gluten free pasta available +2
SANDWICHES
Smash 16 / Hero 19 Served with our simple saladsub Caesar +3
-
OG NYC
classic meatballs, tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese
-
Chicken Parm Parm
chicken meatballs, tomato sauce, parmesan cream sauce, mozzarella cheese
-
The Veggie
house made veggie balls, pesto, mozzarella cheese
-
WANNA MAKE YOUR OWN?
choose your ball and sauce!
Smash $17
Hero $20
-
ULTIMATE HERO
add 4th ball to any hero +3
add our swift kick hot sauce to any item +2
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. Classic meatballs contain beef and pork. We are not a nut-free kitchen. Please alert your server if you have any allergies. The meatball shop is a registered trademark
Ice Cream Sandwiches
choose your ice cream and your cookie $8-
Ice Cream
half baked
vanilla bean
cherry garcia -
Cookie
chocolate chip
snickerdoodle
double chocolate chunk
special cookie
-
Make It A Double Decker
your choice of three cookies and two scoops of ice cream |
$13
-
Blast From The Past
top your ice cream sandwich with the cereal of the day +1
for double decker + $2
-
Carousel Red Velvet Cake
Smooth as velvet, thick cream cheese frosting
$12
Coffee
-
Espresso
$4
-
Americano
$4
-
Cappuccino
$5
-
Latte
$5
-
Grady's Cold Brew Iced Coffee
$4.50
Tea
-
Peppermint
$4
-
Earl Grey
$4
-
Green
$4
-
Iced Tea
$3.50
FOOD
$8-
Mozzarella B’alls
with classic tomato sauce
-
Margherita Flatbread
tomato sauce, mozzarella
-
The OG Flatbread
classic balls, tomato sauce, mozzarella
-
Mini Buffalo B’alls
Frank's Red Hot, blue cheese
-
TMS Caesar
romaine with crispy capers and garlic croutons
-
Big Italian
chopped salad with pepperoncinis, artichokes, green olives, chickpeas, grana and traditional Italian vinaigrette
-
Crispy Calamari
with spicy-ish tomato sauce
-
Spaghetti & Meatballs
2 classic meatballs, spaghetti, tomato sauce
-
1/2 OG NYC Hero
classic meatballs, tomato sauce, mozzarella
served with a side salad -
1/2 Lasagna
crushed classic b'alls, ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce
served with a side salad
BEER
$5-
Narragansett Pint
lager, Rhode Island
-
Lagunitas IPA Pint
india pale ale, California
-
Six Point Crisp Pint
pilsner, Brooklyn NY
WINE / PUNCH
$5-
Sangria
seasonal
-
Glass of TMS White
Italy, 2017
-
Glass of TMS Red
France, 2017
-
Fool-Aid Punch
brandy, rum, citrus, grape drink
COCKTAILS
$8-
any house liquor cocktail
13
Choose Your Meatball
-
Classic
-
Chicken
-
Veggie
Pick Your Sauce
-
Classic Tomato
-
Parmesan Cream
-
Plain
Select Your Side
-
Spaghetti
-
Rigatoni
-
Mashed Potatoes
-
Daily Veg
vegan | gluten free | gluten free option |
For seated dining, we request parties of 10 or more to order from our Family Style Menu package. For $39 per person, select 2 ball and sauce combos, 1 salad, 3 sides, and 2 ice cream sandwich combos! All dishes are served for everyone to share.
Don't worry if one of your guests has special dietary restrictions - We can swap out their side or balls for something just for them!
Download PDFChoose Your Balls
Choose 2 Combos of Balls + Sauce-
Classic
-
Chicken
-
Spicy Heritage Pork
-
House-Made Veggie
Salads
Choose 1-
Simple Salad
shaved radish, red wine vinaigrette
-
TMS Caesar
romaine, crispy capers, garlic croutons
-
Big Italian
pepperoncini, artichokes, green olives, chickpeas, italian vinaigrette
Sides
choose 3-
TMS Creamy Mac & Cheese
cheddar, grana, parmesan cream
-
Roasted Broccoli
chili, garlic
-
Cauliflower
roasted then fried, caesar seasoned
-
Mashed Potatoes
with butter and chives
-
Polenta
freshly milled from Wild Hive farm, grana
-
Spaghetti, Rigatoni or Cavatappi
choose a sauce, topped with grana
gluten free pasta +2/person
Beverage Packages
-
**2 Hour Packages for Tables Only**
-
Beer + Wine
unlimited draft beer, Shop white + Shop red
30/person -
Beer, Wine + 2 Specialty Cocktails
unlimited draft beer, Shop white, Shop red + your choice of two speciality TMS cocktails
40/person -
Well Open Bar
open bar with well liquor, beer, wine, sangria + all of the TMS specialty cocktails
50/person -
Premium Open Bar
full open bar including all liquors, beer, wine, sangria + all of the TMS specialty cocktails
75/person
Choose Your Sauce
-
Classic Tomato
-
Spicy Meat
-
Pesto
-
Parmesan Cream
-
Veggie Ragù
-
Spicy-ish Arrabbiata
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Choose 2 combos-
Ice Cream
vanilla bean
half baked
cherry garcia -
Cookies
chocolate chip
snickerdoodle
double chocolate chunk
1/2 sandwich/person
Upgrade to a full sandwich + 4/person
Add it on! Family Style
-
Mini Buffalo Balls
Frank's red hot, blue cheese
$39
-
Mozzarella Balls
with classic tomato sauce
$39
-
Garlic Bread
18
add mozz +9 -
Crispy Calamari
with spicy-ish tomato sauce
$51
Starters
-
Garlic bread
with tomato sauce
small 25 / large 50 -
Garlic bread w/Mozz
with tomato sauce
small 35 / large 70 -
Focaccia Slices - 1 Dozen
$6
-
mini Buffalo B'alls
24 mini balls with Franks red hot, blue cheese
39
Salads
-
Simple Salad
shaved radish, red wine vinaigrette
small 50 / large 100 -
TMS Caesar
romaine, crispy capers, garlic croutons
small 50 / large 100 -
Big Italian
pepperoncini, artichokes, green olives, chickpeas, italian vinaigrette
small 50 / large 100
Veggies & Sides
-
Mashed Potatoes
with butter and chives
small 50 / large 95 -
Polenta
freshly milled from Wild Hive farm
small 50 / large 95 -
Broccoli
roasted with chili and garlic
small 50 / large 95 -
Cauliflower
roasted, caesar seasoned
small 50 / large 95 -
OTHER SIDES / VEGGIES AVAILABLE
please see our regular menu for additional seasonal sides
Balls & Sauce
We recommend 3-4 balls per person-
20 Balls
choose your ball and sauce
75 -
45 Balls
choose your ball and sauce
150 -
-----
-
B'ALLS
Classic [contains pork]
Spicy Heritage pork
Chicken
House-made veggie -
Sauce
Tomato sauce
Spicy meat
Parmesan cream
Pesto
Veggie ragu
Spich-ish Arrabbiata
Pasta
-
Rigatoni, Spaghetti or Cavatappi
your choice of sauce
small 50 / large 95 -
Gluten free pasta
your choice of sauce
small 60 / large 115 -
TMS Creamy Mac & Cheese
cheddar, parm cream, grana
small 60 / large 115 -
Cavatappi Chicken Pesto
mini chicken meatballs, broccoli, cavatappi
small 110 / large 190 -
Rigatoni Spicy Pork
spicy pork b'alls, broccoli, parm cream, swift kick
small 110 / large 190 -
Rigatoni Shrimp
tomato cream sauce, cherry tomatoes, calabrian chili
small 150 / large 280 -
Lasagna
crushed classic b'alls, ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce
one size, serves 15-18
150
Dessert
-
Cookies - 1 Dozen
chocolate chip, double chocolate chunk or snickerdoodle
no mix and match
24
Add On Items
-
Cutlery Sets
plate, fork, napkin
$0.50
-
Heating Sets
1 rack with aluminum pan, 2 sternos
$12
Food Packages
priced per person-
package one / 18
2 meatball and sauce combos, 2 sides, 2 cookies
-
Package two / 32
1 meatball and sauce combo, 2 from plates & pastas, 1 salad, 1 side, 1 ice cream sandwich
-
Package three / 50
2 meatball and sauce combos, 3 from plates & pastas, 1 salad, 2 sides, 2 ice cream sandwiches
Salads
each additional selection +$5pp-
Simple Salad
shaved radish, red wine vinaigrette
-
TMS Caesar
romaine, crispy capers, garlic croutons
-
Big Italian
pepperoncini, artichokes, green olives, chickpeas, grana, italian vinaigrette +2 pp
Plates & Pastas
each additional selection +$8pp-
TMS Creamy Mac & Cheese
cavatappi parm cream, cheddar, grana
-
Seasonal Risotto
-
Classic Spaghetti & Meatballs
classic balls, tomato sauce, spaghetti +4 pp
-
Chicken Pesto
mini chicken meatballs, broccoli, cavatappi +4 pp
-
Rigatoni Spicy Pork
spicy pork balls, broccoli, parm cream, swift kick +5 pp
-
Chicken Parm
buttermilk marinated, mozzarella, tomato sauce +5 pp
-
Rigatoni Shrimp
tomato cream sauce, cherry tomatoes, calabrian chili +6 pp
-
gluten free pasta available
Beverage Packages
-
**3 Hour Packages**
-
Beer + Wine
unlimited draft Beer, Shop white + Shop red
40 per person -
Beer, Wine + 2 Specialty Cocktails
unlimited draft beer, Shop white, Shop red + your choice of two speciality TMS cocktails
50 per person -
Well Open Bar
open bar with well liquor, beer, wine, sangria + all of the TMS specialty cocktails
65 per person -
Premium Open Bar
full open bar including all liquors, beer, wine, sangria + all of the TMS specialty cocktails
100 per person
Sm'all Bites
al la carte-
Garlic Bread
with tomato sauce 18
add mozz cheese 9 -
mini Buffalo Balls
Franks red hot, blue cheese
$39
-
Mozzarella Balls
with classic tomato sauce
$39
-
Crispy Calamari
with spicy-ish tomato sauce
$51
-
Bruschetta
marinated tomatoes, seasoned ricotta
$42
Choose Your Balls
-
Classic
contains pork
-
Chicken
-
Spicy Heritage Pork
-
House-Made Veggie
white bean & broccoli
Choose Your Sauce
-
Classic Tomato
-
Spicy Meat
-
Pesto
-
Parmesan Cream
-
Veggie Ragu
-
Spicy-ish Arrabbiata
Sides
each additional selection +$4pp-
Mashed Potatoes
with butter and chives
-
Polenta
freshly milled from Wild Hive farm
-
Broccoli
roasted with chili and garlic
-
Cauliflower
roated then fried, caesar seasoned
-
Kale
sauteed, white wine, garlic
-
Rigatoni / Spaghetti / Cavatappi
choice of sauce
gluten free pasta +2 pp -
Other Sides / Veggies Available
please see our regular menu for additional seasonal sides
Ice Cream Sandwiches
-
Ice Cream
vanilla bean
half baked
cherry garcia -
Cookies
chocolate chip
snickerdoodle
double chocolate chunk